← notes from the desk

On membership

Notes on turning people down

Every month we write about a hundred notes to people we're not inviting in. It's the part of the job that shapes the room more than any other.

by Rohan Kapoor · January 30, 2026 · 4 min

01

Roughly a hundred applicants are declined each month, each with a written note.

02

Every no defines the room more than any yes does.

03

About one in nine reapplies a year later — and many become the best members.

The politest, most careful part of running a membership.

Every month we write about a hundred notes to people we're not inviting in. Sometimes because it isn't the right time. Sometimes because it isn't the right fit. Occasionally because the reference calls said something we can't unhear. In every case, we write the note ourselves.

It sounds precious. It's actually the most operationally important thing the desk does. Every no shapes the room more than any yes — because a good room is defined at its edges, not its centre. Who isn't at the table is what makes the people who are, want to keep showing up.

About a hundred of these are written every month.
About a hundred of these are written every month.
A good room is defined at its edges, not its centre.

The notes are short. They say what we noticed, they say what would have to change, and they say the door isn't closed. About one in nine comes back a year later, and about a third of those come back with the thing we asked for. Those are, more often than not, some of our best members.

It turns out the way you say no is the way you say what you're for.

Filed by the desk. Quibbles to hello@baaaz.club.

We print four of these a year, on paper, and post them.
Ask about the letter.

Members get it in the post. Everyone else reads it here, a week later.